Does Ice Cream Go Bad in the Freezer? Explore Here

So, you’ve got a tub of Ben & Jerry’s, and you’ve eaten half the tub during your movie marathon… Fantastic, we’d do the same thing since we have a sweet tooth! But when you place your ice cream in the freezer, it leaves you with a thought: does ice cream go bad in the freezer? And if it does, when is it time to chuck it into the bin?

We answer all your questions about ice cream shelf life and its expiration date, so read on!

Does Ice Cream Go Bad In The Freezer?

Ice cream needs no introduction. It’s a delicious sweet we love having for desserts or pairing with baked goods.

As the name suggests, it obviously lives in the freezer when we aren’t busy eating. Since freezing is a standard preservation method, it’s easy to presume that ice cream can last for years.

Unfortunately, that’s not the case. Ice cream can go bad even when it stays in the freezer. After all, it is still food, most of which have a finite shelf life. Plus, given that ice cream is usually made of dairy, it would expire at one point.

BUT, Why Does Ice Cream Expire?

The typical ice cream contains a host of frozen dairies, such as condensed milk, cream, eggs, and butterfat.

While all these ingredients are pasteurized and frozen before being sold, it’s still dairy, and it will expire over time, even when in the freezer. (*)

Think of ice cream as frozen milk, which lasts just a bit longer than dairy milk in terms of shelf life.

It’s not fine cheese you’ll want to age because when it spoils and you take a big bite, it might make you hate ice cream forever.

And let’s not forget the fact that there’s a risk of freezer burn, which has bacteria infesting your ice cream!

When you open your tub, its contents become vulnerable to bacteria, as sugar becomes an incubator for tiny parasites.

Besides that, with the difference between freezer and room temperature, ice cream’s moisture levels will change from the heat and humidity, which affects its texture.

If you leave it outside, it will also attract insects, making it less appealing to eat.

There is also a chance of food poisoning when you refreeze melted ice cream, as bacteria have had a chance to grow and multiply while the ice cream is out of the freezing temperature.

That’s why you must scrape off the melted part of ice cream before placing the tub back in the freezer.

How Long Does Ice Cream Last in The Freezer?

Supposedly, ice cream’s shelf life is up to two months for unopened packs, and after that, the quality starts to falter.

Once you do open, the clock starts ticking, and we only have about a month or two to finish it without risk of spoilage.

That said, it’s worth noting that the best-by labels you see on the tub are a bit conservative.

Some people mention that you can eat unopened ice cream tubs 2-3 months past the printed date!

So, if an unopened tub of ice cream can last for 2-3 months past its printed date, how about the shelf life of opened tubs?

Opened ice cream, it can last for 1-2 months past its printed date. However, we recommend consuming within three weeks of opening it to get the quality flavor still.

There are also other types of ice cream with different expiry dates, such as:

• Unopened sherbet lasts for 3-4 months past its printed date
• Opened sherbet lasts for 2-3 months pasts its printed date
• Ice cream cake can only last for one week unless it doesn’t have any cream cheese, whipped cream, butter, or eggs

These dates are only a general assumption and under proper storage conditions.

Depending on the brand and how you store it, it can last longer or shorter than the best-by date suggests.

How can you tell if ice cream has gone bad?

If you have left ice cream in the freezer for a considerable amount of time, it’s best to check if it’s gone bad before consuming it. These are the signs to watch out for:

• If you see ice crystals, your gelato may have gone bad and needs to be thrown out, as it has experienced freezer burn. You can scrape the tiny ice crystals off, but the taste will be off.
• You see some mold growth and insects in the tub.
• There is an odd smell or taste, similar to expired milk.
• There’s a change in texture, looking gooey with small ice shards that float, looking like a liquid-like substance.

Is It OK To Eat Expired Ice Cream?

A tiny bite to test won’t hurt, but if you consume more than a scoop, then there’s a chance that you can contract foodborne illnesses from the potential bacteria growth.

Here are some of the foodborne illness symptoms you may experience after eating expired ice cream:

• Stomach cramps
• Vomiting
• Fever
• Diarrhea

If you experience any of these symptoms, consult a health care professional and head to emergency care if they worsen.

How to Store

Now that you know about the expiration date, how can you store it properly for it to last longer? Here are a few tips to follow:

• Finish your entire carton in one sitting! It’s the perfect excuse to eat all the ice cream you want. Kidding aside, it’s best to consume within a week, and you can share it with friends to make it easier.
• When freezing your ice cream, make sure it is below 0 degrees Fahrenheit. We do this to avoid freezer burn.
• Place your container at the back of the freezer, which is where your tub won’t be affected by temperature fluctuations as much as you open and close the freezer door.
• Never mix ice cream with odors from frozen onions or stew! Prevent that from happening by placing used tea bags or baking soda in your freezer to prevent mixing odors.
• Never have air get into the ice cream. You can do this by placing them in an airtight container or plastic box, placing plastic wrap on the ice cream, or using special containers designed to store ice cream.

Frequently Asked Questions

Here are some frequently asked questions to help with your ice cream woes!

Wrapping It Up

Does ice cream go bad in the freezer? Ice cream can lasts long as long as you know how to store it properly. Now that you know the shelf life of ice cream and tips on keeping ice cream properly, then follow the information above!

Up Next: What’s The Shelf life of Dairy Products?