Can you substitute Miracle Whip for mayonnaise? | Definitive Guide

img of substitute Miracle Whip for mayonnaise

Can you substitute Miracle Whip for mayonnaise?  Certainly, the big debate is on everyone’s lips!

Mayonnaise is the finishing touch to a potato salad and a tuna or egg sandwich, to name a few. Yet, when you finish your stash, will Miracle Whip yield the same tasty results you seek? Equally, can mayonnaise offer the same results as Miracle Whip?  

We know that Miracle Whip and mayonnaise have similar colors and textures. Yet, these two popular condiments have distinct differences in the manufacturing methods, ingredients, taste, and health benefits.

Keep reading to learn more about each product, understand the differences, and quick and easy homemade recipes. 

What is Miracle Whip Made Of?

Miracle Whip(™) is a trademarked term, which means it is a one-of-a-kind product manufactured and sold by one brand, namely Kraft Foods ®

In 1933, it debuted at the World’s Fair and was soon snatched up off the shelves in grocery stores regularly.  

According to the FDA, any product marked as “Mayonnaise” must contain at least 65% of vegetable oil, and Miracle Whip does not meet these criteria. However, it does meet the other criteria of eggs, vinegar, and seasoning, placing it in the “dressing” category.  

What Does Miracle Whip Taste Like?

You can expect a sweet and tangy taste due to the extra sugar and generous dose of vinegar—the “secret blend” of spices and seasoning delivers the unique taste so many love.  

Learn more: Miracle Whip substitute

What is Mayonnaise Made Of?

Mayonnaise is an emulsified sauce and one of the top condiments in the US. It is not one product manufactured by one brand, like Miracle Whip.

As it meets the FDA (Food and Drug Association) requirements of at least 65% vegetable oil, eggs, vinegar, and seasoning, this popular condiment can boast the mayonnaise title confidently.  

What Does Mayonnaise Taste Like?

The taste of mayonnaise varies from brand to brand. Some will taste more “eggy,” while others offer a zesty lemon or vinegar tang.  

Also, the oil type used in the emulsion heavily impacts the flavor. For example, an olive oil base has a strong and fruity taste compared to sunflower oil, which is more neutral and earthy.

Learn more: Mayonnaise substitute

img of can substitute Miracle Whip for mayonnaise

Mayonnaise Vs. Miracle Whip: The Differences

We understand the sauce or dressing is the finishing touch to your dish, so let’s break down the differences between these two delicious products.

Miracle WhipMayonnaise
Labeled as a dressing, contains less than 65% vegetable oil, not meeting FDA “Mayonnaise” criteria.Labeled as a condiment, spread, dressing, or sauce, contains 80% vegetable oil, meeting FDA criteria
Trademarked brand.Several available brands
Sweet, tangy, secret blend of seasoningSalty, tangy, eggy, taste varies from brand to brand
Color and texture similar to MayoColor and texture similar to Miracle Whip
More cost-effectiveLess cost-effective
More than 20 ingredientsFew ingredients
Unknown ingredients.  Therefore, you can experiment and try to replicate itMade with readily available ingredients.  Therefore, you can make your own to suit your taste
1 tbsp serving: *40 calories, 3.5g of fat1 tbsp serving: *Average of 100 calories, 12g fat, and 2g of saturated fat
Not oilySlightly oily
*Important Note:  The above comparison is based on Miracle Whip Original and an average for mayonnaise due to the extensive available options

Miracle Whip or Mayonnaise: Which is Healthier

Miracle Whip is lower in calories and fat. However, mayonnaise is less highly refined and may be a healthier option.  

That said, you should look for mayonnaise made with healthy oil, such as avocado or olive oil. Mayonnaise with inflammatory oils, such as canola, corn oil, or soybean, offers fewer health benefits.  

Saucy Recipes

Homemade Miracle Whip

We understand that a homemade version of Miracle Whip may differ in taste. However, “whip” up this quick and easy recipe in emergencies!

The Best Ever Homemade Mayonnaise

Mayonnaise has simple, readily available kitchen ingredients. This delicious traditional recipe has excellent step-by-step images to ensure optimal results.  


How is Miracle Whip different from mayonnaise?

Miracle Whip (™) is labled a dressing as it does not meet the FDA criteria of a minimum of 65% vegetable oil. It is a trademarked term manufactured and sold by one brand, namely Kraft Foods ®. Mayonnaise is labled a condiment, spread, dressing, or sauce as it has 80% vegetable oil, meets the FDA criteria, and varies from brand to brand.  

Is it ok to use Miracle Whip instead of mayonnaise?

Yes, you can use Miracle Whip instead of mayonnaise. Although the flavors vary, the colors and texture are similar. Miracle Whip makes an excellent mayonnaise substitute for potato salad, a tune or egg sandwich, a spread or dip base.  

Final Debate Thoughts

Ultimately, you can substitute Miracle Whip for mayonnaise and vice versa.  Of course, the flavor will vary. Yet, the creamy texture remains intact.

If your regular go-to for favorites such as potato salad and tune or egg sandwiches is mayonnaise, consider Miracle Whip. You never know; it may open your palate to a new and exciting taste experience. 

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
Which is your favorite?

About The Author

Scroll to Top